10 Quarterbacks with the Most Super Bowl Wins in 2024

The Super Bowl trophy is football’s ultimate grail! For the quarterbacks who run the offense and call plays, it’s the ultimate reward. The quarterbacks with the most Super Bowl wins make their place in the NFL history books forever, much like reaching the summit.

This blog will discuss several renowned quarterbacks who guided their teams to Super Bowl triumphs. Each of them contributed something unique to the team, whether its the critical plays that changed the game’s outcome, excellent leadership or extraordinary talent. In addition to making their imprint on the game, these winners encouraged younger players to set lofty goals and pursue their Super Bowl dreams.

Also Read: Best Super Bowls Of All Times: Top 10 Iconic Games In NFL History

Which Teams Have the Most Super Bowl Wins?

With six titles apiece, the New England Patriots and Pittsburgh Steelers are the major winners! The Patriots have made the most Super Bowl trips (11) but have also suffered more losses (5 times). The Steelers, on the other hand, have only lost twice in their eight trips there.

This year, San Francisco came dangerously close to being a six-win team, but they lost out. They now share second place with the Dallas Cowboys after winning five Super Bowls apiece.

With four championship victories, the New York Giants and the Green Bay Packers are also not far behind.

10 Best NFL Quarterbacks with the Most Super Bowl Wins

These ten quarterbacks are legendary in the Super Bowl! They acquired that unique Super Bowl ring by leading their teams to victory in the most important game. Await tales of extraordinary skill, astute maneuvers, and breathtaking victories!

1. Jim Plunkett

Plunkett’s narrative is distinct. Plunkett’s tale is one of unanticipated success. Despite not having very remarkable aggregate stats, he won two Super Bowls. He was selected in the 1970 NFL Draft by the New England Patriots and played largely reserve for several teams then. 

However, in 1981, just before the Super Bowl, he was named the Oakland/Los Angeles Raiders starting quarterback due to circumstances (and a few injuries)! Though nobody anticipated much, Plunkett rose to the occasion admirably. In addition to leading the Raiders to an unexpected victory over the Philadelphia Eagles, he was named the MVP of the Super Bowl for his exceptional play. This tale solidified Plunkett’s status as an underdog in Super Bowl history.

Plunkett’s voyage was far from ended. Later, he was benched once more, but in a typical champion manner. He took back his starting job and guided the Raiders to victory against the Washington Redskins in Super Bowl XVIII (1984). He was the first quarterback in history to win two Super Bowls with the same team in separate locations (Oakland and Los Angeles). Thanks to this accomplishment, he is still among the few quarterbacks with the most Super Bowl wins.

• Position: Quarterback
• Jersey number: 16
• Born: December 5, 1947, in Santa Clara, California

2. Bob Griese

The driving force behind the Miami Dolphins’ undefeated season, Bob Griese, wasn’t just about impressive numbers or highlight-reel throws. He was an efficiency virtuoso who guided his group with poise and determination.

Grisee had difficulties along the way to winning the Super Bowl. In 1967, he was selected by the Dolphins and originally split time as a quarterback with another player. Bob Griese wasn’t known for his spectacular plays or clever throws, but he was a winner all the way around. Griese ultimately claimed the lead in 1971, following an early battle for the starting position. He masterminded the Miami Dolphins’ 14-0 season, which stands as the only NFL unbeaten season in history!

But Griese was more than just fortunate. He was a dependable team player who could control the situation and maintain his group’s concentration. The Dolphins defeated the Washington Redskins 14–7 in Super Bowl VII, demonstrating his ability to remain composed under stress. Even though the score wasn’t a massive blowout, Griese’s astute play-calling and leadership were a significant factor in the victory.

• Position: Quarterback
• Jersey number: 12
• Born: February 3, 1945 in Evansville, Indiana

Also Read: Top 10 NFL Teams With The Most Super Bowl Wins

3. Roger Staubach

Famously known as “Captain America” of the Dallas Cowboys, quarterback Roger Staubach was more than simply a two-time Super Bowl champion. Beyond the game, he was a cultural hero, a leader, and a role model.

Staubach took an unconventional route to football success. The Dallas Cowboys selected him in the 64 NFL Draft, but he had to postpone his football career to serve in Vietnam as a member of the Navy. When he came back in 1969, he had to work hard at first, but Staubach’s talent and perseverance were evident. After gaining the starting job, he guided the Cowboys to a successful period in the 1970s.

Staubach was more than simply a talented passer; his leadership qualities, intellect, and spirit of competition were contagious. He coordinated an extremely potent offensive scheme known as “Doomsday” with illustrious partners like Lance Alworth, the wide receiver, and running back Calvin Hill. The result of this was two Super Bowl victories: the Miami Dolphins in Super Bowl VI (1972) and the Denver Broncos in Super Bowl VIII (1974), which made him rightfully own a place among the best NFL quarterbacks.

• Position: Quarterback
• Jersey number: 12
• Born: February 5, 1942 in Cincinnati, Ohio

4. Troy Aikman

Dallas Cowboys quarterback Troy Aikman earned the moniker “gunslinger” for his audacious tosses while leading his club to three Super Bowl victories. With that extra championship title, Aikman takes the lead over Ben Roethlisberger, who has also won two Super Bowls.

Football is a team sport, and Aikman undoubtedly benefited from playing with some outstanding teammates. With players like wide receiver Michael Irvin and running back Emmitt Smith, the Dallas Cowboys were a formidable team in the 1990s. Unquestionably, this outstanding supporting group made Aikman shine.

It’s important not to undervalue Aikman’s leadership qualities and pivotal moments. He was renowned for remaining composed under duress and making accurate throws at crucial junctures. He was the mastermind behind this gifted offensive, which saw the Cowboys win three Super Bowls: XXVII (1993), XXVIII (1994) against the Buffalo Bills, and XXX (1996) against the Pittsburgh Steelers. In his first Super Bowl appearance, he even won the MVP award.

• Position: Quarterback
• Jersey number: 8
• Born November 21, 1966, in West Covina, California

5. Bart Starr

Before the days of explosive passing schemes and quarterbacks obsessed with stats, the Green Bay Packers’ best NFL quarterbacks were guided to triumph by the unassuming general Bart Starr, who did so with perseverance and guts.

Although he is a Hall of Fame quarterback, Bart Starr wasn’t well-known for his absurd stat line or extremely long passes. His stats (152 touchdowns and 138 interceptions) may look mediocre compared to today’s quarterbacks.

Fitting in well with Vince Lombardi’s power-running, ball-controlling style, he led the storied attack. Though Starr’s numbers may not surprise you, he played a significant role in the 1960s Green Bay Packers success. He had a reputation for being composed and producing clutch throws when the game was close. He became the first quarterback in history to lead the Packers to consecutive Super Bowl victories (Super Bowl I and II)!

• Position: Quarterback
• Jersey number: 15
• Born: January 9, 1934, in Montgomery, Alabama

6. Eli Manning

Eli Manning may not be ranked #1 on every “greatest of all time” list, but this two-time Super Bowl champion quarterback for the New York Giants has cemented his unique position in NFL history with his clutch efforts against the invincible Tom Brady and the New England Patriots.

Manning’s narrative is one of exceeding expectations to become the quarterback with the most Super Bowl wins. Pressure was on him when he joined the league in 2004 after being drafted first overall. But in Super Bowl XLII (2008), he disproved his detractors by guiding the Giants to an unlikely triumph over the much fancied Patriots. His last-second touchdown ball to receiver David Tyree solidified his legacy among the Giants.

Yet Eli wasn’t a one-hit wonder. After four years, he repeated the action! Manning pulled off another stunning victory over the formidable Patriots in Super Bowl XLVI (2012), which brought him another MVP award. These two victories cemented Manning’s reputation as a big-game player who could step up to the plate when it counted most.

• Position: Quarterback
• Jersey number: 10
• Born: January 3, 1981 in New Orleans, Louisiana

Also Read: Chasing Super Bowl Dreams: 11 NFL Teams That Never Won A Superbowl

7. John Elway

The tale of John Elway, popularly known as the “Comeback Kid,” is that of tenacity mixed with gridiron triumph. Although he helped the Denver Broncos win two Super Bowls, his rise to the top wasn’t without setbacks.

Elway was drafted by the Denver Broncos in 1983, but his early career was characterized by three consecutive heartbreaking Super Bowl defeats (Super Bowls XXI, XXII, and XXIII). Elway became known for these losses and was dubbed “The Comeback Kid” for his heroic but ultimately unsuccessful attempts.

But Elway never wavered in his resolve. He kept improving as he guided the Broncos to many postseason berths. The tide finally shifted in Super Bowl XXIV (1990). Elway silenced his naysayers and erased years of despair with a commanding victory over the San Francisco 49ers, thus becoming one of the best NFL quarterbacks. He even proved his skeptics wrong by winning the prized MVP award for the Super Bowl.

• Position: Quarterback
• Jersey number: 8
• Born: November 21, 1966, in West Covina, California

8. Joe Montana

Next on this list is the quarterback Joe Montana, the indisputable “King” and, in the opinion of many, the “Greatest Of All Time” (GOAT), having won an incredible four Super Bowls. The San Francisco 49ers, a team that young Tom Brady grew up idolizing, were the sole reason he accomplished this amazing achievement.

On the field, Montana was more than simply a champion. He was a magician gifted with an uncommon blend of poise, talent, and clutch capability. Known as “Joe Cool” because of his composed manner in stressful situations, he was able to execute drives that would win games with incredible accuracy at critical points.

After being drafted by the 49ers in 1979, Montana had an instant effect. He guided the group to its first-ever Super Bowl victory against the Cincinnati Bengals in Super Bowl XVI (1982), taking home the MVP award. A dynasty was only getting started. In addition to winning two additional Super Bowls (1985 against the Miami Dolphins and 1989 against the Cincinnati Bengals, in which Montana delivered a historic game-winning touchdown throw), Montana and the 49ers dominated the league during the 1980s.

• Position: Quarterback
• Jersey numbers: 16, 19
• Born: June 11, 1956, in New Eagle, Pennsylvania

9. Tom Brady

Top of the list with an incredible seven Super Bowl titles is none other than Tom Brady— the champion’s champion! There’s no disputing his status as the greatest quarterback with the most Super Bowl wins and possibly one of the greatest athletes, even after his retirement, continues to amuse followers on social media.

Brady’s supremacy is nearly unfathomable. He began playing with the New England Patriots, where he and head coach Bill Belichick built a legendary squad. They collectively won six Super Bowls: XXXVI (2002), XXXVIII (2004), XXXIX (2005), XLIX (2015), LI (2017), and LIII (2019). Brady became known as the ideal clutch player, guiding drives that resulted in game-winning touchdowns and consistently exceeding expectations.

• Position: Quarterback
• Jersey number: 12
• Born August 3, 1977 in San Mateo, California

10. Peyton Manning

The “Sheriff” with the golden arm and the astute intellect, Peyton Manning, is the last quarterback on our list. Although his two Super Bowl triumphs cemented his status as one of the NFL’s best quarterbacks, his influence on the game extends well beyond titles.

Manning’s remarkable intelligence, lightning-fast precision, and game mastery marked his career. Known for his ability to manage and maintain order during team meetings, he analyzed defenses mentally and executed blows with extreme accuracy. After being selected in the 1998 NFL Draft by the Indianapolis Colts, he rose to fame and helped the club advance to Super Bowl XLI (2007), where the Chicago Bears defeated them.

Even with the early disappointment, Manning’s adventure went on. A neck ailment resulted in his release from the Colts. Still, this did not mean that the great quarterback was done. In 2012, he joined the Denver Broncos, and started an incredible journey all over again.

• Position: Quarterback
• Jersey number: 18
• Born: 24. March 1976 in New Orleans, Louisiana

Conclusion

In football, winning the Super Bowl is the ultimate reward! These best NFL quarterbacks direct plays and ensure their team scores, acting as team captains. We examined ten outstanding quarterbacks who won Super Bowls with their clubs. Every individual contributed something exceptional, from Joe Montana’s remarkable four titles to Tom Brady’s seven triumphs that broke records and others who showed distinctive abilities, poise, and clutch performances. In addition to impacting the game, these icons encouraged aspiring quarterbacks to aim high and win a Super Bowl.

Also Read: NFL: Ten Reasons For Its Enduring Popularity Among Fans

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):